diff --git a/mods/ITEMS/mcl_potions/potions.lua b/mods/ITEMS/mcl_potions/potions.lua
index 545b11876..938fdde6e 100644
--- a/mods/ITEMS/mcl_potions/potions.lua
+++ b/mods/ITEMS/mcl_potions/potions.lua
@@ -855,10 +855,18 @@ local function replace_legacy_potion(itemstack)
 	return new_stack
 end
 local compat = "mcl_potions:compat_potion"
+local compat_arrow = "mcl_potions:compat_arrow"
 minetest.register_craftitem(compat, {
 	description = S("Unknown Potion"),
 	_tt_help = S("Right-click to identify"),
-	image = "mcl_potions_dragon_breath.png",
+	image = "mcl_potions_potion_overlay.png^[colorize:#00F:127^mcl_potions_potion_bottle.png^vl_unknown.png",
+	on_secondary_use = replace_legacy_potion,
+	on_place = replace_legacy_potion,
+})
+minetest.register_craftitem(compat_arrow, {
+	description = S("Unknown Tipped Arrow"),
+	_tt_help = S("Right-click to identify"),
+	image = "mcl_bows_arrow_inv.png^(mcl_potions_arrow_inv.png^[colorize:#FFF:100)^vl_unknown.png",
 	on_secondary_use = replace_legacy_potion,
 	on_place = replace_legacy_potion,
 })
@@ -876,11 +884,11 @@ for _, name in pairs(old_potions_2) do
 	minetest.register_alias("mcl_potions:" .. name .. "_2", compat)
 	minetest.register_alias("mcl_potions:" .. name .. "_2_splash", compat)
 	minetest.register_alias("mcl_potions:" .. name .. "_2_lingering", compat)
-	minetest.register_alias("mcl_potions:" .. name .. "_2_arrow", compat)
+	minetest.register_alias("mcl_potions:" .. name .. "_2_arrow", compat_arrow)
 end
 for _, name in pairs(old_potions_plus) do
 	minetest.register_alias("mcl_potions:" .. name .. "_plus", compat)
 	minetest.register_alias("mcl_potions:" .. name .. "_plus_splash", compat)
 	minetest.register_alias("mcl_potions:" .. name .. "_plus_lingering", compat)
-	minetest.register_alias("mcl_potions:" .. name .. "_plus_arrow", compat)
+	minetest.register_alias("mcl_potions:" .. name .. "_plus_arrow", compat_arrow)
 end
diff --git a/textures/vl_unknown.png b/textures/vl_unknown.png
new file mode 100644
index 000000000..279a4cdb0
Binary files /dev/null and b/textures/vl_unknown.png differ