Many land mobs in water #3263

New Issue

Preass · 2023-01-05T20:13:47+01:00

Preass commented

2023-01-05 20:13:47 +01:00

MineClone2 version:

What happened?

I always see many land mobs in water.

What should happen:

They should try to go to land if in water.

Steps to reproduce

Spawn many animals near water and wait. Many mobs will be in water.

MineClone2 version: ### What happened? I always see many land mobs in water. ### What should happen: They should try to go to land if in water. ### Steps to reproduce Spawn many animals near water and wait. Many mobs will be in water.

Preass added the

bug

unconfirmed

labels 2023-01-05 20:13:47 +01:00

Michieal commented

2023-01-06 07:44:25 +01:00

This is a duplicate of the bouncing mobs in water / flying animals.

They fall into the water and then cannot get out. Hence "too many land mobs in water."

I can say, though, that this is a lot better than what happens in MCL5. In those worlds I would have an entire zoo in the ocean off shore by about 12-15 nodes. hundreds of bouncing animals all refusing to go back to land.

While this happens in mc also, it's a fundamental issue with pathfinding in both games. the animals will randomly pathfind to a destination without checking to see if that location is land, or if they can actually get there. So, the animals end up doing the lemmings thing where they all walk off a cliff.

This is a duplicate of the bouncing mobs in water / flying animals. They fall into the water and then cannot get out. Hence "too many land mobs in water." I can say, though, that this is a lot better than what happens in MCL5. In those worlds I would have an entire zoo in the ocean off shore by about 12-15 nodes. hundreds of bouncing animals all refusing to go back to land. While this happens in mc also, it's a fundamental issue with pathfinding in both games. the animals will randomly pathfind to a destination without checking to see if that location is land, or if they can actually get there. So, the animals end up doing the lemmings thing where they all walk off a cliff.

ancientmarinerdev commented

2023-01-06 15:14:12 +01:00

You're spot on on the pathfinding. I think this is a separate bug from the flying mobs issue which is a lag/floating/distance issue. This can be solved by pathfinding tweaks.

I do want to look into pathfinding to stop them walking off cliffs, so I guess once I've learned more I can consider this also.

You're spot on on the pathfinding. I think this is a separate bug from the flying mobs issue which is a lag/floating/distance issue. This can be solved by pathfinding tweaks. I do want to look into pathfinding to stop them walking off cliffs, so I guess once I've learned more I can consider this also.

❤️ 1

ancientmarinerdev added

mobs

and removed

unconfirmed

labels 2023-01-06 15:14:38 +01:00

Michieal commented

2023-01-07 07:33:41 +01:00

Well, if the pathfinding stops them from going into the water, then there will be less bouncing / flying mobs. Though, apparently we also need to check mobs to make sure that they do not spawn in / underwater... I forget the issue, but Nicu raised it.

And, the Original Post is correct, they need to head to land, if in water.

Well, if the pathfinding stops them from going into the water, then there will be less bouncing / flying mobs. Though, apparently we also need to check mobs to make sure that they do not spawn in / underwater... I forget the issue, but Nicu raised it. And, the Original Post is correct, they need to head to land, if in water.

kneekoo commented

2023-01-07 07:36:26 +01:00

we also need to check mobs to make sure that they do not spawn in / underwater... I forget the issue, but Nicu raised it.

Mobs can spawn underwater: #2692

> we also need to check mobs to make sure that they do not spawn in / underwater... I forget the issue, but Nicu raised it. Mobs can spawn underwater: #2692

❤️ 1

Michieal commented

2023-01-07 07:37:11 +01:00

Yep, that's the one! lmao. Thank you, Nicu

👍 1

ancientmarinerdev added this to the 0.83.0 - Safe and Sound milestone 2023-01-10 23:44:10 +01:00

ancientmarinerdev referenced this issue

2023-01-26 21:53:46 +01:00

bug mobs #3360

ancientmarinerdev modified the milestone from 0.83.0 - Safe and Sound to 3 - Near future

2023-03-05 16:10:11 +01:00

teknomunk referenced this issue

2024-07-08 00:51:17 +02:00

Improve mob smartness (cliffs, paths) part 1 #4479

kno10 commented

2024-07-08 11:37:53 +02:00

Should be resolved by #4479 to a large extend. Non-water mobs avoid water, and head to shore when 5 blocks away.
Please help test #4479 for remaining issues.

Should be resolved by #4479 to a large extend. Non-water mobs avoid water, and head to shore when 5 blocks away. Please help test #4479 for remaining issues.

Sign in to join this conversation.