Cannot collect water in bucket #2223

New Issue

EUSRAKWE · 2022-05-22T01:31:26+02:00

EUSRAKWE commented

2022-05-22 01:31:26 +02:00

I'm using Mineclone 2 on Android 11 with Minetest 5.5.0. With a bucket selected, I cannot obtain water, regardless of the depth of water or my location (e.g. on the edge of a lake, bottom of the ocean, sinking in water, perched atop a block in the middle of the ocean). I am able to dig with the bucket. Breaking a sand block gets me sand, not water. Double tapping the screen has no effect (double tapping the screen places water in plain minetest).

When playing only minetest, I am able to obtain water.

I'm using Mineclone 2 on Android 11 with Minetest 5.5.0. With a bucket selected, I cannot obtain water, regardless of the depth of water or my location (e.g. on the edge of a lake, bottom of the ocean, sinking in water, perched atop a block in the middle of the ocean). I am able to dig with the bucket. Breaking a sand block gets me sand, not water. Double tapping the screen has no effect (double tapping the screen places water in plain minetest). When playing only minetest, I am able to obtain water.

cora commented

2022-05-22 01:40:58 +02:00

yeah the mcl2 buckets work fairly differently on a technical level. I mean generally mobile isn't really supported but maybe @AFCMS has an idea?

chmodsayshello added the

controls

#P6: low

labels 2022-05-22 15:22:40 +02:00

chmodsayshello commented

2022-05-22 15:23:52 +02:00

adding low priority since both Android and iOS are not supported, and the controls label should be obvious

kneekoo added the

mobile

label 2022-06-17 00:47:44 +02:00

Ghost commented

2022-07-24 14:49:30 +02:00

for what its worth, mc5 buckets work.

cora commented

2022-07-24 15:49:56 +02:00

Pretty sure they worked last I tried - yes they behave very unpredictably but about the same as in mcl5 I think.

I mean I did change a few minor things in buckets so maybe I broke it but pretty sure it was working when I tested water mobs and the change was before that so idk.

for what its worth, mc5 buckets work.

Maybe clarify what exactly doesn't work...

Pretty sure they worked last I tried - yes they behave very unpredictably but about the same as in mcl5 I think. I mean I did change a few minor things in buckets so maybe I broke it but pretty sure it was working when I tested water mobs and the change was before that so idk. > for what its worth, mc5 buckets work. Maybe clarify what exactly doesn't work...

cora commented

2022-07-24 16:22:11 +02:00

mmh doesn't look like this could have broken it but I'll try when I'm back home.

3a7022ab66

mmh doesn't look like this could have broken it but I'll try when I'm back home. https://git.minetest.land/MineClone2/MineClone2/commit/3a7022ab66b430a7bbe06d93135942a9ea184c82

Ghost commented

2022-07-24 16:23:23 +02:00

Maybe clarify what exactly doesn't work...

mcl5: I am able to place and collect liquids from any side.
mcl2: I can not collect any liquids.

I think this is a bug in the android client.

> Maybe clarify what exactly doesn't work... mcl5: I am able to place and collect liquids from any side. mcl2: I can not collect any liquids. I think this is a bug in the android client.

cora commented

2022-07-24 16:25:05 +02:00

I'll say again that android is not supported; but it does seem weird that it supposedly works in mcl5.

AFCMS commented

2022-08-26 11:47:32 +02:00

yeah the mcl2 buckets work fairly differently on a technical level. I mean generally mobile isn't really supported but maybe @AFCMS has an idea?

The only thing that I see is the controls.register_on_press() function.

Maybe its not working for some reason on android, IDK.

> yeah the mcl2 buckets work fairly differently on a technical level. I mean generally mobile isn't really supported but maybe @AFCMS has an idea? The only thing that I see is the `controls.register_on_press()` function. Maybe its not working for some reason on android, IDK.

kneekoo commented

2022-08-26 12:24:56 +02:00

The following Minetest info might be an explanation, although I'm not sure if it covers this specific issue:

Mobile devices (Android / iOS)

The controls on mobile devices are severely restricted compared to the PC and you only have very basic controls. You can't do everything a PC player could do.

The following [Minetest info](https://wiki.minetest.net/Controls#Mobile_devices_.28Android_.2F_iOS.29) might be an explanation, although I'm not sure if it covers this specific issue: > ### Mobile devices (Android / iOS) > > The controls on mobile devices are severely restricted compared to the PC and you only have very basic controls. **You can't do everything a PC player could do.**

Sign in to join this conversation.